Heinously Unreliable Used Car Battle of the Week: Early 90s American Muscle Heinously Unreliable Used Car Battle of the Week: Early 90s American Muscle

Posted in Top Stories by Common Gearhead | Views: 7424

Welcome to the latest installment of HUUCBOTW, where the cars are actually more reliable than CNN's reporting. This week, we turn our attention to the greatest country in the world: this one! (Results may vary).

Is there anything more American than squeezing ridiculously pitiful amounts of horsepower out of oversized, lethargic engines? If you answered no, then you're wrong! The answer was "over-optimistic misguided patriotism." However, seeing as this is a car-related website, let's just pretend the first answer was correct.

This is not the first time we've revisited the late 80s and early 90s, and while our friends in Japan were starting to get things right again with their cars, America was still getting things horribly, disastrously wrong. But amongst all of the angular turds we were churning out, there are still some cars from this era that are loved by both enthusiasts and dudebros alike. And today, we get to look at two of them! Yee haw!

So fire up your walkman, turn on some Full House or Family Matters, and take the poll at the end to pick your favorite American "muscle" car!

1991 Chevrolet Camaro Z28 - $4,995


The all-knowing Jeremy Clarkson once dubbed this generation of Camaro "a murderer's car" when he purchased one to drive through the Southern US, and I don't think a more fitting description has been devised for anything else ever. But with every dark cloud, there is a silver lining: the Z28 is a fast murderer's car!

Of course, when I say "fast" I mean "faster than the RS version" which was about as quick as getting a bill through Congress. This 1991 Z28 comes with a 4-speed automatic (booooo) and a 5.0L V8 pushing out 230 horses when new. Bearing in mind annual horsepower depreciation and many murderous miles, it probably puts out the equivalent of one horse's leg today.

23 years ago it hustled to 60 miles per hour in 9.5 seconds, which leads me to believe that many previous owners are now behind bars for unsuccessfully attempting to flee from the law.


Being an American car from any time in, oh I don't know, the past 100 years, it has a lot of rust issues. But thankfully, parts are easy to come by and a few simple upgrades can turn this Z from sleepy to sleeper without breaking the bank.

To see the Cars.com ad for this car, click here.

Check out more Chevy Camaro listings on Ebay Motors here!

1993 Ford Mustang LX 5.0 - $5,700


I've always been a Mustang guy, but I've got a bit of an issue with the Fox Body. Fanboys will go on and on about how it's light, cheap, relatively powerful, and "comparatively good looking" for the time period. But they're all wrong... it's downright hideous. I mean, it looks like they completely forgot to integrate headlights into the design, and when it came time to present the prototype to their bosses, they said "dammit Jerry, get me a saw and the headlights from that Taurus over there!"

But despite its complete lack of show, the 5.0 had a decent amount of go for its time, pushing out 205 horses. And best of all, it's a liftback! So much more room for activities!

Fanbros are quick to mention that they're cheap to maintain and upgrade and are capable of putting out irresponsible amounts of horsepower and noise. Nothing quite like giving some pensioner a heart attack as you peel out of the Walmart parking lot, is there?


What they won't tell you, however, is that upon cornering the Fox experienced about as much body roll as Bring It On: All or Nothing. Don't ask me how I know this, it's not important.

To see the Craigslist ad for this car, click here.

Check out more Ford Mustang listings on Ebay Motors here!

Which one would you have? Take the poll and let us know!

P.S. I'm just now realizing that "American Muscle" is a play on American Hustle. You're welcome.


Want to read more from the Common Gearhead?

Check out more articles at CommonGearhead.com

Also, consider supporting us by bookmarking the Amazon.com link below and using it before you buy anything. It costs you nothing extra, and it lets us keep producing free content for car people everywhere. Thanks for your support!




  • Here's The Real Reason Why /DRIVE Started Charging For Content

    Views: 15719

    If you're a car enthusiast, chances are, you've seen a /DRIVE video, but you probably also saw that they were one of the first major channels that have moved to a premium model of content, meaning that each month, the subscriber gets charged to watch the high-quality videos the channel puts out. Admittedly, people were pissed and many theories came about as to why a channel with that many loyal followers would do such a drastic move. Mike Spinelli, one of /DRIVE's main personalities, puts all the rumors to rest in a quite reasonable way. 

    | Read More »

  • How Can You Get 200,000 YouTube Subscribers Starting From Nothing?

    Views: 6238

    Regular Car Reviews may be the funniest car channel on the internet today, bar none. It combines quick-witted, super-specific references with toilet humor and insightful commentary to make something that you can't help but binge watch. In this edition of Offtrack, I sat down with Mr. Regular as he explained to me why Delaware isn't such a great state and why people get weird when they meet celebrities. This may get odd. 

    | Read More »

  • Here's The One DIY Guide Every BMW Owner Must See

    Views: 20849

    BMWs are great cars for the most part. Their performance per pound make them a serious competitor in the market for people that want a thrilling driving experience. But they do have an achilles heel: The cooling system. As the system is sealed, meaning that there's nowhere to bleed off air when in normal running condition, bleeding the system properly is one of the most important things you can do to keep your car running for years to come. Here's how to do it, the right way. 

    | Read More »

All auto modifications and repairs listed at APiDAOnline.com are to be done at your risk. APiDAOnline.com does not, at any point, assume responsibility of any injury, damage, or charges that may occur through modifying or repair of your or anyone else's car. Car modifications are to be done at your discretion and should be done by qualified individuals. Please check your motor vehicle regulations regarding any car modifications or car tuning you may do to ensure they are street legal.